9-Inch vs 8-Inch Cake Pan: Volume, Bake Time & Tips

byCrumbleo -June 11, 2025

0

9 Inch Vs 8 Inch Cake Pan: What’s the Difference?

For successful baking, selecting the appropriate cake pan size can be surprisingly crucial. Cake thickness, baking time, batter volume, and, finally, the final texture and appearance of your cake are all impacted by the minor distinction between an 8-inch and a 9-inch cake pan.

Knowing these distinctions enables you to modify recipes with confidence and get the best results possible, whether you're a home baker or a recipe developer.

Impact on Baking

Because a 9-inch pan is larger than an 8-inch pan, cakes made in a 9-inch pan will be thinner. Compared to an 8-inch pan, you must increase the batter volume by roughly 25% to make a thicker cake in a 9-inch pan. Keep a close eye on the baking time because thinner cakes bake more quickly.

Size and volume comparison

9-inch round pan (2 inches deep) holds about 8 cups of batter.
8-inch round pan (2 inches deep) holds about 6 cups of batter.

Pan Area (Surface for Baking)

9-inch pan area ≈ 63.5 square inches
8-inch pan area ≈ 50.3 square inches

Volume Equivalents

9-inch pan holds the same batter volume as an 8x2 inch square pan or a 9x5 inch loaf pan.
8-inch pan is equivalent to about 3/4 of the volume of a 9-inch pan.

Why Scaling Matters?

You may be tempted to follow the recipe exactly as it is written, but resist the urge. Although it may not seem like a big difference, a 9-inch round pan is actually more than 25% larger than an 8-inch pan. Because of this, your cake may overbake in addition to being thinner.

Scaling your cake (or brownie, blondie, or buckle) recipe to fit your preferred pan size is a much better option. Even though the recipe might not work out exactly like the original, your chances of success will be much higher than if you just winged it.

Simply dividing the area of the desired pan by the area of the original pan will yield that conversion factor. Each ingredient is then multiplied by that percentage. If you don't want to brush up on your math, you can look at our chart below. We have calculated the most popular pan sizes for you.

Original Pan

Desired pan

6-inch round

8-inch round

9-inch round

8x8 square

9x9 square

13x9

8-inch round

0.6

1.0

1.3

1.6

2.3

9-inch round

0.5

0.8

1.0

1.3

1.8

Simply calculate your conversion percentage using the chart below, then multiply each ingredient in your recipe by that figure. For instance, multiply each ingredient by 1.8 to bake a 9-inch round cake in a 13 by 9-inch pan. Additionally, you won't need to scale your ingredients at all for some conversions.

More Tips for Success

Round fractions that are awkward. Round up to 2.5 teaspoons rather than attempting to measure, say, 2.37 teaspoons.
Beat an entire egg and then measure out the portion you need to measure. Two tablespoons would yield half an egg, since a typical large egg is equivalent to roughly four tablespoons.
Think about your gear. Will the recipe still work in a stand mixer with a lower volume, or would a hand mixer be more effective? Will you have to make two batches with a higher volume?
Don't depend on the recipe's timings. Scaling a recipe can alter baking times as well as mixing or processing times. When given visual cues, use them.
Maintain reasonable expectations. Although understanding this basic math can greatly enhance your results, keep in mind that baking requires accuracy, so your recipe might not turn out precisely as it did in the original.

10 Cake Pans Tips for Beginner Bakers

The fundamentals of cake pans and some advice on how to achieve the best results for each layer you bake are essential for anyone just starting out in baking.

Size matters: Although some cake pans have a slight flare at the top, most are measured across the bottom. Use a pan that is 8 inches across the bottom if the recipe specifies an 8-inch pan.

Prep pans correctly: Line the bottom of the pan with silicone pan liners, waxed paper, or baking parchment paper to ensure the cake comes out of the pan.

Professionalism isn't the answer: You don't need to purchase extremely costly pans; standard aluminum ones will work well, conduct heat evenly, and cool down fast.

Prior to de-panning, level: Before removing the cake, level it off with the top of the pan. Using the top edge of the pan as a guide, cut off the cake's domed top with a long bread knife. When assembling the cake layers, it will provide you with a level surface.

Trim before frosting (occasionally): Since square pans rarely provide perfectly straight edges, you can trim the sides after filling the cake but before crumb coating. If there are a lot of extra crumbs on the sides of round cakes, you can also tape them off to make icing them easier.

Use caution when handling batter-filled pans: Keep a firm hold on batter pans when you are moving them around, or they may suddenly flip out of your grasp and spill batter all over the floor.

Cake layers should be cooled and kept in the pans: To keep the layers from shattering, let the cakes cool in the pans. The structure won't cool down and the cake may crumble if you attempt to turn out the layers too soon. To help the bottoms cool more quickly, place them on cooling racks that allow air to circulate beneath the pans.

Develop a fondness for cake collars: Employing cake collars in your pans will help you level the cakes more easily and prevent batter overflow by allowing you to bake the layers slightly above the pan's edge.

The best is metal: Because ceramic, silicone, and glass cake pans don't conduct heat as well as metal ones, you'll need to modify the baking times.

Large cakes bake more evenly when piping nails are used: To help the middle of the batter heat up evenly, you may need to use an upside-down piping nail or a baking core if your pan is larger than 10 inches.

The baking time may be impacted and the outside may dry out if the pan's sides heat up and the batter bakes on the outside more quickly than the inside.

Conclusion: 9 Inch Vs 8 Inch Cake Pan

The batter volume, cake thickness, and baking time are all greatly impacted by the seemingly insignificant difference between an 8-inch and 9-inch cake pan. Knowing these differences and how to modify recipes accordingly will guarantee that your cakes always turn out flawlessly.

Knowing how to scale your recipes and selecting the appropriate pan size will enable you to bake with confidence and produce delectable results, regardless of your preference for thinner layers or taller, narrower cakes.

Related Recipes & Tips: